5. Sammy Davis Jr. – Candy Man 4. Warrant – Cherry Pie 3. Bow Wow Wow – I Want Candy 2. Don McLean – American Pie 1. Van Halen – Ice Cream Man Honorable Mention The Cars – Candy-O DNCE – Cake by the Ocean Four Tops – I Can’t Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Honey Bunch) Led Zeppelin – Custard Pie Montrose – Rock Candy Motley Crue – Slice of Your Pie Van Halen – Poundcake